Stalking Buffalo Again on America's Plains
At the end of the 1800s, the bison, also known as the American buffalo, was one herd shy of becoming extinct. But now the free-ranging beasts are making a comeback -- so much so that buffalo meat is back on market shelves.
Yet a sour economy and little demand for the rich meat is making life hard for many buffalo ranchers. Matt Hackworth of member station KCUR in Kansas City, Mo., reports that the price for buffalo meat is so low, some ranchers are opening their herds to hunters willing to pay for the chance to stalk the enormous animals.
"The life price for selling (buffalo) has gone down to where you can't make a profit at it," says Vance Hopp, who keeps a buffalo herd on a one-mile-square tract on his family's ranch in Kansas. "It costs you as much to grass one of these buffalo cows for the year as... a calf's worth at a year old now." He tells Hackworth he'd lose money if he sold his herd of buffalo at a livestock market.
One reason is that supply greatly outmatches demand for buffalo meat. And because of the severe drought affecting huge areas of the nation and the lack of pasture grass, ranchers bear the cost of feeding the animals. The solution? "They say the best way to make money on their buffalo is to allow hunters to shoot them," Hackworth reports.
On a recent cold and windy day, Danny Ewing and Larry Mitchell -- two factory workers from Hutchinson, Kan. -- stalk a buffalo bull on Hopp's ranch. Bulls can't be sold at auction, mostly because they are too difficult to put in pens or transport. The hunters each paid Hopp $750 to hunt buffalo -- something Ewing says he's always wanted to do, because it's a challenge.
"A buffalo has got a mind of his own," Ewing tells Hackworth. "You don't tame a buffalo like you do a cow... because they got a mind of their own, they do what they want anyway."
Because these hunts are on private property, state hunting laws don't apply -- and hunters can use anything from a rifle to a bow and arrow to stalk and kill their prey. Temple Grandin, an assistant professor of animal science at Colorado State University who researches humane slaughter techniques, says shooting and killing buffalo in the field can be the most humane way of harvesting the meat.
The problem, Grandin says, is determining the skill of the hunter. "If you have good hunters who are good shots do it, it'd be a very humane way. But if you have Joe Public who comes out and blasts away -- and maybe hits him in the foot -- that's not responsible."
Ranchers like Hopp say they try to find responsible hunters. "And with prices at an all-time low, they have little choice but to allow hunters to cull their herds until the market for buffalo meat rebounds," Hackworth says.
Copyright 2021 NPR. To see more, visit https://www.npr.org.